The Fermilab ARISE Project

Air Pollution: A Local and Global Problem

Scenario

Synopsis

References

Student Pages

Index

Students in Ms. Bardeen's regular chemistry class, grades 10,11,12, at Oak Park and River Forest High School (OPRF) in Oak Park, IL, enter the computer lab, access the internet on their computers, and begin to work with their teams on their current project. Students are busy talking with one another and their teacher as they investigate the problem of air pollution in Chicago and around the world.

OPRF is a four year (9-12) comprehensive high school with an enrollment of approximately 2800 students. The communities of Oak Park and River Forest are located just west of Chicago. Student backgrounds vary greatly socio-economically (low to high), ethnically (63% Caucasian, 28%African-American, 4% Hispanic, 4% Asian) and culturally. Average student standardized test scores are above the state and national averages. The chemistry class is a cross section of the lower 70% of the school community.

A week after students were asked to find and interview a person who as asthma or to interview a doctor about asthma, they enter the classroom and the teacher asks them to pair up with another student and share the results of their interview. The teacher is moving from group to group listening to various discussions, occasionally asking a question. put in some sample comments,here or after next sentence? The teacher then asks the class to create a list of common problems people have with asthma, what actions they have to take, and what can trigger asthma or make it worse. After the discussion the teacher says that the person wants to move to a new city or country and asks the class which triggers could be different. One of the triggers mentioned is high air pollution levels. The teacher then discusses the unit project that the students will complete for the end of the year. The goal of the project is to investigate the problems that Chicago and another city or country has with air pollution using a variety of tools (laboratory technology, internet resources, multimedia technology, etc.) and to propose the best possible solutions to the areas air pollution problems. The students will need to prepare a presentation to discuss the problems and explain their possible solutions using supporting arguments and informantion. The groups will present their projects to the class and send the information to someone in the city or country they researched. The teacher presents the class with a list of possible locations and tells them that by tomorrow the students must form groups of 4 students and sign up for one of the locations to researach.

The next day the teacher discusses the timeline for the project. The students will have to give weekly updates on progress. The students have formed home groups and selected a location around the world that they wished to investigate. The teacher then asks each home group to brainstorm for 5 minutes makeing lists of what they know and what they need to know. After 5 minutes the teacher askes if the students need more time and the class wants another 5 minutes. The teacher then has the class to compile their lists together on the board. The class then looks over the list to see if any new ideas are developed. Each home group then works together to develop a plan for conducting their research. They initially determine what tasks they what to accomplish to address the problem, decide who will do each task and when they will report back to the group. They create an action plan on the computer and ensure that everyone, including the teacher has a copy of the plan.

Each group has designated someone to look for information about the location, another person to search for an official from the location that they can communicate with, and a third person to search for schools in their location that they could collaborate with on the internet. When the class enters the computer lab several goups of students create their own subgroups. Each subgroup contains students from different home groups but the students are trying to find similar types of information. Refine these examples. For example, one group is using Netscape to search for information about their locations on the World Wide Web using a search engine. One student in the group has used a search engine to find a page that lists The teacher is assisting another group in a discussion on what officials they might be able to contact and how to locate them on the Internet or by other means. The teacher asks how they are going to initiate contact with the official, how they will describe what they are doing and what questions they are going to ask. The students then share ideas with each other on accomplishing this task.

The project on air pollution is in the third week of the 4-8 week inquiry. All but one of the groups have identified the air pollution problem in their location through their searches on the World Wide Web and their contact with local officials and organizations. The students have met with their home group to discuss what types of pollutants are in their area and they redefine and reassign the tasks they want to accomplish. As the students enter the computer lab today they join new subgroups each looking for specific information about different pollutants. For example, one group of students is searching for information about SOx pollutants and another group is looking for information about NOx pollutants. One group of students is learning from the computer resource teacher how they can use the available software programs to make graphics that can show the chemical reactions involved with the different pollutants. The teacher is meeting with one home group that has not redefined their tasks yet. After determining what the students have already done in their search, the teacher encourages them to look for more information, guiding them toward areas they have not yet tried.

The students have one more week to work on their project before presenting it to the class, they are now working with their home groups designing a presentation. The computer resource teacher is helping one group to incorporate a video that they have found into their presentation. As the other teams work on their presentations, the teacher is moving from group to group. The teacher provides feedback and assistance and keeps track of noted problems and progress. She talks with students about their plans and decisions about strategies, organization and unique presentation ideas.

Technology aspects pending


Author: Karen Bardeen
The Fermilab ARISE Project sponsored by Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory Education Office and Friends of Fermilab. Funded by the The Illinois State Board of Education.
Created: July 3, 1997 - Updated: July 11, 1997
/arise/projects/kbardeen/scenario.html